Covering a stock completely during simmering prevents evaporation, which concentrates flavors and clarifies the stock. Leaving the lid slightly ajar allows steam to escape, resulting in a clearer, more balanced stock.
Simmering stock involves gently heating bones, vegetables, and aromatics in water over a prolonged period. The goal is to extract flavor and collagen from the ingredients. When you cover the pot completely, you trap all the steam inside. This steam condenses and drips back into the stock, preventing the reduction of the liquid. Reduction is crucial because it concentrates the flavors, making the stock richer and more intense.
Furthermore, a tightly covered pot can lead to a cloudy stock. As the stock simmers, impurities and fats rise to the surface. If the steam is trapped and condenses, these impurities are more likely to be stirred back into the stock, resulting in a less clear final product. Leaving the lid slightly ajar allows some steam to escape, carrying away some of these impurities and preventing excessive condensation. This helps to maintain a clearer, more refined stock.
Use a lid that is slightly offset or tilted to allow steam to escape while still preventing excessive heat loss. This balances the need for evaporation with maintaining a consistent simmering temperature.