Perfectly cooked tomato paste will be a deep, brick-red color, have a rich, concentrated tomato flavor, and will have slightly caramelized around the edges of the pan. It should also be significantly reduced in volume.
Cooking tomato paste properly is crucial for developing its flavor and removing any raw, acidic notes. Here's a breakdown of the signs that indicate it's perfectly cooked:
Color Transformation: Raw tomato paste is typically a bright red. As it cooks, the color deepens to a brick-red or even a rusty brown. This indicates that the sugars in the tomatoes have begun to caramelize.
Aroma: The aroma will change from a fresh, slightly acidic tomato smell to a richer, sweeter, and more concentrated tomato fragrance. You might even detect subtle nutty or caramelized notes.
Appearance: You'll notice the paste reducing in volume as the water evaporates. The edges of the paste in the pan might start to caramelize and stick slightly. This is a good sign, but be careful not to burn it.
Flavor: The raw, acidic taste of uncooked tomato paste will mellow out, and a deeper, sweeter, and more complex tomato flavor will emerge. Taste a tiny amount (carefully, as it will be hot) to check for this transformation.
Don't overcrowd the pan when cooking tomato paste. Use a wide pan to maximize surface area and speed up the evaporation process. Stir frequently to prevent sticking and burning, especially towards the end of the cooking process.