Potato skins are removed for various reasons, including texture preference, aesthetic appeal, and to reduce the intake of certain compounds like glycoalkaloids, which can be bitter or, in very high concentrations, toxic.
Removing potato skins before cooking is a common practice driven by several factors. Firstly, some people simply prefer the smoother texture of peeled potatoes in dishes like mashed potatoes or gratins. The skin can sometimes be perceived as tough or detract from the overall creamy consistency.
Secondly, aesthetics play a role. Peeled potatoes often present a cleaner, more uniform appearance in certain dishes, which can be desirable for presentation purposes.
Thirdly, and perhaps most importantly, peeling potatoes can reduce the levels of glycoalkaloids. These naturally occurring compounds are concentrated in the potato skin and eyes. While generally harmless in small amounts, high levels of glycoalkaloids can impart a bitter taste and, in rare cases, cause digestive upset. Green potatoes, in particular, have elevated levels of glycoalkaloids and should be peeled thoroughly or avoided altogether.
Finally, some recipes require peeled potatoes to achieve the desired cooking result. For example, certain potato salads benefit from the uniform texture of peeled potatoes, allowing the dressing to coat them evenly.
If you're concerned about nutrient loss when peeling potatoes, consider leaving a thin layer of skin on or opting for varieties with thinner, more palatable skins that don't require peeling at all. New potatoes, for example, often have very thin skins that are perfectly edible and nutritious.